We elect Members of Parliament to represent us, serve the nation and get things done. Above all, we expect them to work.
We do not elect them simply to spend five years fighting the people sitting on the opposite benches.
When we recruit someone into a business, we expect them to contribute to its success. We expect them to work with their colleagues, challenge poor decisions, offer better ideas and take responsibility for the results.
We don't expect everyone to agree. In fact, we actively encourage disagreement when it produces better decisions. But we do expect everyone to work towards a common purpose.
Why, then, do we expect so much less from the people we elect to run our country?
Parliament should be no different. We elect 650 individuals, each entrusted with the responsibility of serving the public.
We elect them to work together, not to work against one another.
One Parliament. One workforce.
Under this proposal, voters elect their constituency MPs. Once elected, those MPs choose the Prime Minister. No political party automatically forms the government. Political affiliations, convictions and competing visions remain, but they do not decide who is allowed to contribute to governing.
The Prime Minister appoints the best qualified people to lead departments, regardless of their affiliations. The Chancellor might be Conservative, Labour, Liberal Democrat or independent. The question is not which rosette they wear, but whether they can do the job.
Each minister works alongside a parliamentary committee whose members receive the relevant evidence and help develop decisions. Every MP has a genuine role. Parliamentary service becomes a full time occupation with responsibilities, not a platform for perpetual campaigning.
More ideas. Less manufactured opposition.
This is not an appeal for politicians to stop disagreeing. Quite the opposite. Fifty different ideas for solving a problem are more interesting than two rehearsed party positions and a few variations around the edges.
Party whips would no longer control parliamentary votes. MPs would follow their judgement, conscience, promises to constituents and the evidence. Committees and inquiries would be allocated fairly through lottery or rotation, while leadership roles would go to those most suited to them.
Let representatives argue vigorously about the merits of proposals. Let the arguments produce better solutions. When a ministerial committee cannot reach consensus, a further group of MPs helps examine the disagreement. If that fails, the responsible minister makes the decision and accepts responsibility for it. Dissent and reasoning are recorded rather than hidden.
We will know this has worked when...
Those seven words should stand at the beginning of every proposed law or reform. Before it can proceed, its sponsors must state what success looks like and how it will be measured. Call it a Policy Performance Target.
No credible definition of success? The proposal does not get off the starting blocks.
Independent assessment would compare what a policy promised with what it achieved. Some results would be too early to judge; others would be partly successful, unsuccessful or fully successful against their declared aims. The public should see both the original expectations and the eventual evidence.
Passing a law is not the achievement. Achieving the purpose for which it was passed is the achievement.
Ten words of accountability
Every official parliamentary vote should carry a short public explanation from each MP: ten words at most to explain support, opposition or abstention. Their voting history, assigned work and contributions should be easy for constituents to inspect.
That record should not become a government issued league table of good and bad politicians. A vote against a policy that later succeeds may have reflected legitimate concerns about cost or unintended consequences. Publish the vote, the reason and the result. Let the electorate judge.
Voting is a duty, but endorsement is a choice
Participation in public elections should be compulsory, with a meaningful penalty for unjustified non participation. Election day should be a public holiday, with non essential services closed and practical arrangements for those whose essential work must continue.
But nobody should be forced to endorse an unsuitable candidate. Every ballot must include a formal None of the Above option, counted equally with the candidates. If None of the Above beats the leading candidate, nobody is elected. A fresh contest follows with new candidates.
That makes rejection a democratic decision with consequences, not a discarded protest.
Keep the ballot on paper
We can use technology to support electoral administration, but the authoritative vote should remain a physical paper ballot, available for independent scrutiny and recounting.
The right to vote is too precious to surrender to a machine we cannot see inside, a system we cannot independently verify or a person we are simply expected to trust.
Elected to work. Accountable for results.
Imagine a Parliament where ministers are chosen for ability, MPs are expected to contribute, disagreements create better ideas and every reform must say what it intends to accomplish. Imagine being able to see not just how your MP voted, but why, and what happened afterwards.
Being elected should not be treated as a victory over an enemy. It should be treated as an appointment to serve the public.
We don't elect politicians to fight each other. We elect them to work for us.
This article presents a proposed model for democratic reform, not a description of current UK constitutional arrangements. Detailed institutional design and safeguards would require separate examination.