Cocteau in the occupied capital

When German forces occupied Paris in June 1940, Jean Cocteau remained in the city. He was then fifty years old and already one of the most conspicuous figures in French cultural life: a poet, playwright, novelist, visual artist, filmmaker and social celebrity whose work moved easily between the avant garde and popular entertainment.

Cocteau did not withdraw into private life and he did not join the organised Resistance. Instead, he continued to write, stage plays, work in cinema and promote the career of the actor Jean Marais, his lover and principal artistic collaborator. This public activity placed him within the officially permitted cultural life of occupied Paris. It also placed him in the morally uncertain territory between ordinary survival, artistic continuity, social accommodation and cultural collaboration.

Cocteau frequently presented himself as essentially nonpolitical. He treated poetry and friendship as belonging to a realm above national and ideological divisions. That belief is essential to understanding his behaviour, but it cannot settle the moral question. In an occupied country, the decision to remain publicly visible and to associate with representatives of the occupying power had political consequences whether or not the artist acknowledged them.

Theatre as work, refuge and public spectacle

Parisian cultural life did not cease during the occupation. Theatres, cinemas and music halls attracted large audiences seeking entertainment, warmth and temporary escape from shortages, censorship, curfews and fear. Continuing to perform could be understood as maintaining French cultural life, but performances also took place within a system controlled by German authorities and distorted by the exclusion of Jewish artists and businesses.

Cocteau threw himself into this theatrical world. La Machine à écrire opened in April 1941, with Marais playing the twin roles of Pascal and Maxime. Cocteau later staged Renaud et Armide in 1943 and supervised a revival of Les Parents terribles. His wartime theatre was not overt Resistance drama. Its characteristic subjects were myth, identity, secrecy, forbidden desire and people imprisoned within social roles. Such themes could acquire particular force under occupation, although it would be too convenient to interpret every ambiguity as a concealed political message.

La Machine à écrire brought Cocteau into conflict with Alain Laubreaux, a dramatic critic for the violently antisemitic collaborationist newspaper Je suis partout. Laubreaux attacked Cocteau and the play. Marais responded by confronting and beating the critic. François Truffaut later adapted this incident for Le Dernier Métro, in which Gérard Depardieu's character drags a collaborationist critic from a restaurant and assaults him in the street.

The episode illustrates Cocteau's peculiar position. He was not naturally at home within the ideological culture of the French extreme right. Collaborationist writers treated homosexuality, artistic modernism and Jewish influence as evidence of the decadence they believed had weakened the Third Republic. Cocteau and Marais lived together at the Palais Royal and were sufficiently open as a couple to become targets of homophobic abuse. Cocteau could therefore be protected by individual Germans while simultaneously being despised by French admirers of fascism.

Cinema and L'Éternel Retour

Much of Cocteau's wartime energy moved towards cinema. His most important occupation era film project was L'Éternel Retour, released in 1943. Cocteau wrote the screenplay, Jean Delannoy directed and Marais starred alongside Madeleine Sologne. The story transferred the legend of Tristan and Isolde into a contemporary but deliberately unreal setting. It was designed in part to give Marais the heroic romantic role that would establish him as a major film star, and it succeeded spectacularly.

The appearance of the film has remained controversial. Its exceptionally blond and physically idealised leading couple can resemble the racial and bodily imagery favoured by fascist culture. Yet the film does not yield comfortably to a single political interpretation. Its return to medieval French literary culture could be understood as recovering a national inheritance under foreign occupation. Its doomed lovers also challenge conventional family arrangements and the orderly domestic ideals promoted by the Vichy regime.

The most defensible conclusion is that the film reflects the contradictions of Cocteau's wartime position. It contains imagery that could sit beside the aesthetics of fascism, elements compatible with Vichy ideas and other elements that resist the prescribed social order. It is neither straightforward propaganda nor reliable evidence of covert resistance.

The affair of Arno Breker

The most serious stain upon Cocteau's wartime reputation was his relationship with Arno Breker. Breker was Hitler's favoured sculptor and produced monumental, idealised male figures closely associated with Nazi conceptions of racial strength, physical perfection and heroic masculinity.

In May 1942, an exhibition of Breker's sculpture opened at the Musée de l'Orangerie in Paris. German officials and prominent French collaborators attended. The event presented artistic exchange as evidence of cultural accord between France and Germany, thereby helping to disguise the reality of conquest beneath a performance of civilised friendship.

Cocteau attended the exhibition, visited it privately with Marais and introduced the two men. He then published Salut à Breker, an admiring article about Breker's art. This was not merely a private friendship with a German acquaintance. Cocteau lent his public prestige to an exhibition that functioned as an instrument of occupation propaganda.

His defence rested partly upon the idea that artists shared a higher homeland in which ordinary frontiers ceased to matter. In another age this might have sounded like an attractive statement of artistic internationalism. In occupied France it became an evasion. Germany and France were not meeting as equal cultural partners: one had invaded and governed the other. An artist could not take part in a carefully promoted exhibition and then make the political significance disappear by declaring art to be above national boundaries.

Protection, influence and endangered friends

Cocteau's friendship with Breker was not solely aesthetic. Breker possessed access to the Nazi leadership and could intervene with occupation officials. Cocteau's wartime journal records that Breker provided a means of making contact should Cocteau or Pablo Picasso face serious danger. Breker also used his influence to obtain official passes for Marais.

These connections offered practical protection to a gay modernist artist who was being attacked by the collaborationist press. Cocteau later explained his conduct partly through the need to work and earn money and partly through the usefulness of having a powerful protector. This helps explain his decisions but does not remove their public effect. Protection acquired through a representative of the regime could be personally valuable at the same time as public praise of that representative benefited the regime.

Cocteau also attempted to use his contacts on behalf of people in mortal danger. He tried unsuccessfully to secure the release of his friend Max Jacob, the Jewish poet and artist who was arrested and died in the Drancy internment camp in March 1944. In July, he attempted to intervene for Jean Desbordes, a former lover involved in the Resistance, but Desbordes was killed by the Germans. These efforts matter. They show that Cocteau was capable of personal loyalty and recognised the murderous danger surrounding his friends. They do not retrospectively convert his other activities into resistance.

Liberation and the question of collaboration

After the liberation of Paris in August 1944, Cocteau's conduct came under formal scrutiny. In November he appeared before the committee investigating collaboration in the cinema and was acquitted within minutes. He was also cleared by the writers' committee. Resistance associated writers including Louis Aragon and Paul Éluard supported him. Marais joined General Leclerc's Free French forces and departed for the front in September.

The acquittals are important evidence that Cocteau was not judged a legal or ideological collaborator. He did not become a spokesman for Nazism, advocate German government of France or participate in persecution. Before the occupation he had expressed opposition to racism and antisemitism, while the fascist press regarded him as representative of the very culture it wished to destroy.

Legal acquittal, however, is not the same as complete moral exoneration. Cocteau remained prominent within approved cultural life, cultivated influential Germans and publicly praised Hitler's favourite sculptor during an exhibition designed to advance cultural collaboration. His behaviour belongs in the broad grey field of accommodation rather than at either extreme of treason or resistance.

What Cocteau's case tells us

Cocteau's greatest wartime error may have been his belief that aesthetic judgement could remain morally autonomous. He appears to have believed that personal friendship, beauty and poetry could cross political boundaries without becoming contaminated by them. This allowed him to understand his praise of Breker as recognition of one artist by another, even while the occupation authorities could use that recognition as evidence of Franco-German cultural harmony.

It is therefore misleading to portray him either as a secret hero or as a committed Nazi collaborator. He was gifted, vain, vulnerable, loyal to particular friends and remarkably skilled at maintaining his cultural position. At moments he used that position in an attempt to help others. At other moments he allowed his fascination with personalities and art to obscure the machinery of power surrounding them.

For research connected with Cultural Amnesia, this ambiguity is precisely why Cocteau matters. Cultural memory tends to simplify occupation into the resisters, the collaborators and the silent majority. Cocteau exposes the inadequacy of those neat divisions. His case asks whether continuing to make art preserves civilisation or merely decorates an intolerable political order; whether access to powerful people is justified when it may protect friends; and whether an artist who refuses politics can prevent politics from making use of him.

The most balanced judgement is that Cocteau was not an ideological collaborator, but neither was he politically innocent. He mistook artistic independence for moral neutrality. Occupied Paris demonstrated that neutrality is itself a consequential choice, particularly when an artist's name, presence and admiration are valuable to those who hold power.