A citizen bond designed to turn retirement income into inherited capital
There is a simple idea hiding inside a much larger argument about public debt: if the British state is going to carry a substantial stock of debt for decades, perhaps we should ask not only how much debt exists, but who should own it and what form it should take.
This article explores a proposed Permanent Income Bond: a long term or undated government security sold directly to UK citizens, paying a fixed annual coupon, inheritable by the holder's family and tradable in a secondary market. A limited amount of the annual income could be made tax free to favour ordinary savers rather than very large portfolios.
The political appeal can be stated in one sentence:
Nan's pension becomes the grandchildren's inheritance.
The idea is not that this instrument somehow stops being government debt. It does not. The point is whether part of Britain's existing debt could be converted into a more stable, more domestic and more socially useful form.
Britain has done something similar before
Permanent government bonds are not novel. Britain historically issued undated gilts, including Consols and other perpetual securities, which paid interest without a conventional maturity date. The final four undated UK gilts were redeemed by the Treasury in 2015, ending a form of borrowing with roots stretching back centuries.
Retail government borrowing is also already substantial. HM Treasury's 2026 to 2027 Debt Management Report records about £249.8 billion of National Savings & Investments liabilities within central government sterling debt. In other words, British households already lend very large sums directly to the state.
A Permanent Income Bond would therefore combine two things Britain already understands: retail government saving and long dated sovereign debt.
The proposed design
A workable version might contain the following elements.
- Eligible buyers: UK resident individuals.
- Term: undated or extremely long dated, with no compulsory maturity for the Treasury.
- Income: a fixed coupon set when each issue is launched.
- Inheritance: the security passes through the estate like other financial assets.
- Trading: freely transferable at market value.
- Tax treatment: a modest annual amount of coupon income could be tax free, for example the first £2,000 a year.
- Treasury option: the Government could retain a right to redeem an issue at par under predefined conditions, as Britain historically did with callable undated gilts.
The £2,000 tax free figure above is illustrative rather than a recommendation. At a 5 per cent coupon, it would make the income on the first £40,000 of holdings completely tax free. Someone with a much larger holding would still receive only the same £2,000 annual exemption. That would deliberately concentrate the tax advantage on ordinary household saving rather than creating an unlimited shelter for wealth.
Why a permanent bond would still be government debt
Accounting does not change merely because citizens hold the asset. For the citizen, the bond is a financial asset. For the Treasury, it is a financial liability. It therefore remains public debt.
The potential benefit is not disappearing debt but changing its character. An undated bond has no compulsory refinancing date. The Treasury knows the coupon cost in advance and does not have to find the capital simply because a maturity date has arrived.
That can matter when market interest rates rise. Britain is currently experiencing exactly that problem. On 8 September 2026 the Debt Management Office re-opened its 5⅜ per cent Treasury Gilt 2056 at a gross redemption yield of 5.8168 per cent. The issue attracted strong demand and about 71 per cent of the allocation went to the domestic market.
A retail permanent bond would not make high borrowing costs disappear, but it could remove some future refinancing risk and widen the domestic holder base.
Why it cannot simply trade permanently at face value
There is one important correction to the most attractive version of the idea. A bond cannot normally offer a fixed coupon, trade freely and also be guaranteed always to trade at face value.
A perpetual bond is approximately valued by:
Market value = annual coupon ÷ market yield
Suppose a Permanent Income Bond has a face value of £500,000 and pays a fixed 5 per cent coupon. It produces £25,000 a year.
If comparable market yields are 5 per cent, the simplified value is:
£25,000 ÷ 0.05 = £500,000
If market yields rise to 6 per cent:
£25,000 ÷ 0.06 ≈ £416,667
If yields fall to 4 per cent:
£25,000 ÷ 0.04 = £625,000
The income has not changed. The market value has.
Guaranteeing permanent sale at face value would therefore require the Government itself to stand ready to absorb that price difference. That would turn an undated bond into something closer to an on demand savings product and recreate part of the refinancing risk the design is trying to avoid.
The cleaner model is therefore: fixed coupon, inheritable, freely tradable at market value, with face value remaining the nominal capital amount rather than a guaranteed secondary market price.
What does the income look like?
For illustration, take a fixed coupon of 5 per cent. This is not a proposed launch rate. It is simply a round number for showing the mechanics; any actual issue would have to be priced against prevailing gilt yields, taxation and market demand.
| Face value | Annual coupon at 5% | Gross coupon over 25 years | Nominal capital still outstanding after 25 years |
|---|---|---|---|
| £500,000 | £25,000 | £625,000 | £500,000 |
| £750,000 | £37,500 | £937,500 | £750,000 |
This is the heart of the proposition. If the holder lives for another twenty five years, the £500,000 bond can have produced £625,000 of gross income while the £500,000 nominal claim still exists and can pass into the estate. At £750,000, the equivalent figures are £937,500 of gross income and £750,000 of nominal capital.
That is why the phrase “Nan's pension becomes the grandchildren's inheritance” is not merely rhetoric. The income does not require the holder to consume the nominal capital.
But inflation matters
A fixed nominal bond transfers inflation risk to the citizen. If inflation averaged 2 per cent for twenty five years, £500,000 received or inherited in twenty five years would have purchasing power equivalent to only about £305,000 in today's money. At 3 per cent average inflation, it would be worth about £239,000 in today's money.
The same is true of the fixed coupon: £25,000 a year would buy progressively less if prices continued rising.
This is simultaneously a strength for the Treasury and a weakness for the investor. The Government gains certainty over a nominal liability; the saver accepts uncertainty over its real purchasing power. An index linked version could protect the investor, but would remove part of the fiscal certainty that makes the permanent fixed rate version attractive.
How does this compare with property?
Property is the obvious comparator because British households already use housing as a combined retirement asset, inflation hedge and inheritance vehicle. But the comparison must be handled carefully. A home also provides somewhere to live. A bond does not. The figures below therefore compare the financing and inheritance characteristics, not total welfare.
The Bank of England reports that the effective rate on newly drawn mortgages was 4.45 per cent in July 2026. Using that rate, a 25 year repayment mortgage and a 20 per cent deposit gives the following illustration.
| £500,000 home | £750,000 home | |
|---|---|---|
| Deposit | £100,000 | £150,000 |
| Mortgage | £400,000 | £600,000 |
| Monthly repayment | about £2,212 | about £3,318 |
| Total mortgage repayments over 25 years | about £663,600 | about £995,400 |
| Interest within those repayments | about £263,600 | about £395,400 |
| Current standard SDLT in England | £15,000 | £27,500 |
| Deposit + mortgage payments + SDLT | about £778,600 | about £1,172,900 |
Those figures exclude maintenance, insurance, repairs and other ownership costs, so they are deliberately favourable to the property side of the comparison.
If the property then appreciated at an illustrative 3 per cent a year for twenty five years, a £500,000 house would become worth about £1.047 million, while a £750,000 house would become worth about £1.570 million.
This does not mean the homeowner achieved a pure investment return equal to the difference between the original purchase price and the final value. The household has been making mortgage payments throughout and has also received twenty five years of housing services by living in the property. The point is simply that the headline increase in the house price does not describe the whole financial history of ownership.
Inheritance Tax currently favours the home
Current UK Inheritance Tax rules create an important difference between property and an ordinary financial security.
The standard nil rate band is £325,000. A qualifying residence left to direct descendants can receive an additional residence nil rate band of up to £175,000, taking the potential allowance for a qualifying individual estate to £500,000. A surviving spouse or civil partner may in appropriate circumstances transfer unused allowances, potentially taking a qualifying combined estate to £1 million. The standard IHT rate above the applicable threshold is 40 per cent.
A Permanent Income Bond would not automatically receive that extra £175,000 residence allowance.
Using today's rules as a snapshot, and assuming no other assets or reliefs, a £500,000 bond in a single person's estate would generate about £70,000 of IHT, leaving £430,000. A £750,000 bond would generate about £170,000, leaving £580,000.
| Permanent Income Bond | Current standard allowance assumed | Illustrative IHT | Net inheritance |
|---|---|---|---|
| £500,000 | £325,000 | £70,000 | £430,000 |
| £750,000 | £325,000 | £170,000 | £580,000 |
That comparison reveals a policy choice. If Permanent Income Bonds are intended partly to reduce the extraordinary cultural and tax preference for storing family wealth in housing, policymakers could create a capped legacy allowance for these bonds, perhaps analogous to the £175,000 residence nil rate band. That would make the tax treatment more neutral between leaving a house and leaving a citizen bond.
It would, however, be a genuine tax expenditure. The Government would be giving up future IHT revenue. The proposal therefore needs to be justified by lower financing risk or other social benefits rather than being presented as free.
A property inheritance illustration
To show the scale, suppose the two homes above grew at 3 per cent annually for twenty five years and, purely for illustration, today's individual £500,000 qualifying home allowance still applied at death. This is not a forecast of future tax law.
| Original home | Illustrative value after 25 years at 3% | Illustrative IHT using today's £500k qualifying allowance | Illustrative net estate value |
|---|---|---|---|
| £500,000 | about £1,046,900 | about £218,800 | about £828,100 |
| £750,000 | about £1,570,300 | about £428,100 | about £1,142,200 |
For the £500,000 home, the household would have paid roughly £778,600 in deposit, mortgage payments and current SDLT over the acquisition period, before maintenance. The illustrative net inheritance is £828,100. For the £750,000 home, the equivalent acquisition cash is roughly £1.173 million and the illustrative net inheritance £1.142 million.
Those figures should not be read as evidence that the house produced little or no value. The owner also received twenty five years of accommodation, which is economically substantial. They do show, however, why “I bought it for £500,000 and it became worth £1 million” is an incomplete description of the return once financing and tax are considered.
The Permanent Income Bond is not a replacement for a home
The cleanest use of the instrument is not to ask a household to choose between shelter and bonds. Someone who puts £500,000 into a bond still needs somewhere to live.
The more realistic target is retirement capital and legacy saving. A homeowner who downsizes, a saver with a pension lump sum, an heir receiving capital or somebody who simply wants a predictable sovereign income asset could buy Permanent Income Bonds without being forced to consume the capital to fund retirement.
This makes the product particularly interesting as a complement to housing rather than a substitute for it.
A £500,000 holding at an illustrative 5 per cent coupon would pay £25,000 a year. After twenty five years the holder could have received £625,000 gross while still leaving the security itself to the next generation.
Nan's pension becomes an inheritance.
Would 5 per cent actually be enough?
Not necessarily.
On 8 September 2026 the Government sold 30 year gilts at a yield of 5.8168 per cent. A truly perpetual retail security paying only 5 per cent would therefore be below the yield then available on long dated conventional government debt. Investors would need compensation elsewhere: tax free income, unusually convenient retail access, a redemption option or some other benefit.
That is exactly why the tax free income allowance belongs in the design rather than being a decorative extra. It can make a lower headline coupon more attractive to smaller domestic holders without giving the same proportional subsidy to very large investors.
The coupon rate should therefore be discovered through market testing, not chosen politically because 5 per cent happens to be a pleasing round number.
Would it reduce the national debt?
No, not by itself.
If the Government issued £10 billion of Permanent Income Bonds and spent the proceeds on new programmes, public debt would simply be £10 billion higher.
The proposal becomes relevant to debt reduction only if it is used as part of a wider refinancing strategy. For example, as conventional gilts mature, a portion could be replaced with Permanent Income Bonds sold to domestic savers. The debt stock might initially remain much the same, but some of its characteristics would change:
- less compulsory refinancing at fixed maturity dates;
- a predictable nominal coupon;
- more debt held directly by UK households;
- interest income recycled into domestic household income;
- an asset that can pass between generations without the state having to refinance simply because one holder dies.
This would make the debt different, not make it disappear.
That distinction matters. A serious national deleveraging programme needs two objectives at once: reduce the absolute burden of debt where possible, and make the debt that remains cheaper, safer and less destabilising.
The policy question
The Permanent Income Bond therefore deserves further modelling, not because it is a magical solution to public debt, but because it connects several existing facts in a useful way.
Britain already has hundreds of billions of pounds of retail government liabilities through NS&I. Britain has centuries of experience with undated sovereign debt. British households already place extraordinary value on assets that combine retirement security with inheritance. And the Government currently faces unusually expensive long term refinancing.
A citizen owned permanent bond could convert some of that problem into a different relationship:
The state receives patient domestic capital.
The citizen receives predictable lifetime income.
The family inherits the asset rather than merely the memory of the pension payments.
The hard questions remain: what coupon would attract buyers, how much income should be tax free, whether any inheritance allowance is justified, how secondary market liquidity would work and how much of conventional gilt issuance could realistically be replaced.
Those questions can be modelled.
The underlying proposition is already clear enough to deserve doing so.
Nan's pension becomes the grandchildren's inheritance, while Britain converts part of its refinancing problem into patient domestic capital.